Hiya!
- Alexa Mintah
- Alexandria, better known as Alex or Alexa, is a strange Christian-fangirl-YA-writer medley tucked away in an undisclosed location in Virginia. She loves creating worlds out of keystrokes, discovering adorable ships (platonic or romantic), and becoming besties with clever characters who wow her with love and brilliance. When only half spellbound by her many worlds of words, she can be found working amongst the stacks in her local library.
Searching for Something?
Blog Archive
-
▼
2015
(134)
-
▼
November
(10)
- Fandom Videos: Hary Potter: The War
- Posts of the Week: 11.15.15-11.21.15
- Ten Ridiculous Things In Twilight That Kept Me Fro...
- Melodic Mondays: Secrets by Jennifer Thomas (cover)
- Posts of the Week: 11.8.14-11.14.15
- Ten Things About Twilight That Almost Turned Me In...
- Melodic Mondays: Chasing Cars by Snow Patrol
- Posts of the (last three) Weeks: 10.18.15-11.7.15
- Thoughtful Thursdays: A Ramble About My NaNo Proje...
- Melodic Mondays: Everyday by The High School Music...
-
▼
November
(10)
I haven't read Twilight, mostly because I'm not into romance or vampires. (Mosquitoes give me enough trouble.)
ReplyDeleteI like the comment about homeschooling. I get a bit annoyed at all the books out there were the character is an alien, vampire, werewolf, or some other thing that can't easily stay secret, and yet they end up in public school. Seriously, homeschooling is a good option for any nonhumans or superpowered people out there. Of course, if they were homeschoooled, the whole scene where the school finds out what they are wouldn't work. :P
LOL, fair enough. ;)
DeleteThat was kind of a joke, but seriously, it /is/ kinda true. I mean, it would make it a lot more difficult to work the plot, but for the characters, it would make /so much more sense./
And hey, maybe they could go to co-op, or a homeschool group, or 4-H, or something like that and the secret gets discovered there. *shrugs* There are actually a lot of places one could go with that... *mind runs off with plot bunnies*
Thanks for commenting! :)
(Dear Shar: I can be predictable if I want.)
ReplyDeleteSo, originally this comment was so long that Blogger didn’t let me publish it so I will just say oops I wrote a really long response sorry.
(1) I guess I can see why Edward’s mood swings are annoying, especially because they’re so detrimental to Bella, but I believe that when Edward suffers from an existentialist moral crisis he actually has some reason to his fears, and when his moral self-hatred conflicts with his natural feelings and instincts he gets muddled and moody. It’s not excusable that he’s so arbitrary, but it makes sense.
(2) Also, I can sympathize with the Cullens quite a bit, too.
First, they need to fit in. Times change over 100 years. Going to high school is a good way to keep up with your age group because if you go and kick it in the woods for ten years, and then come back to learn that the frosted tips so aren’t a thing anymore, then where will you be? Looking like you know nothing of life or teenagers, that’s where. (And not that homeschoolers kick it in the woods for ten years but a vampire could viably kick it in the woods for ten years under the pretense of home school.)
Second, several of the vampires are actually not coping with being vampires very well. Going to school is normal for them and helps them feel more human. The inherent human-ness of high school is cathartic, maybe.
And, last, the Cullens want to be in a community. And it isn’t that homeschoolers are useless or not in community, because they are, but in the case of the Cullens, if all they did was stay home I think they would feel useless and alone. They still want to be valuable! Carlisle is a doctor. Esme decorates. And so I’d guess that Alice, Jasper, and Edward find satisfaction in offering their gifts in the environment they choose to be in, because Carlisle wouldn’t make them go if they didn’t want to. Plus, they’re only going to be in high school three years, tops, and Bella just caught them in that stage of the cycle.
TL;DR: Despite what might seem logical to someone trying to avoid detection, the goal of the Cullens’ lifestyle is truly not to remain hidden but rather to still be valuable citizens, which they can’t do at home.
(3) Yeah, that’s actually super annoying and I don’t know what’s wrong with those boys or Bella’s interpretation of it.
(4) I see your point, but it’s not how I personally felt.
(5–7) I think the best way for me to understand this is the physical mental transformation that happens when a vampire meets his or her mate. We can tell from other worldbuilding events that vampires find one mate and then mate for life, the end. Physically their brain changes so they love that person alone, and it’s permanent. In the event of Edward, this is simply what happens to him. His brain has physically bonded itself to Bella, and so he always acts on that. In the event of Bella, I feel like because it was almost like she was born to be a vampire, her brain might have tried to compensate by falling in love with Edward the same way, but since she was a human it went a little haywire and didn’t get resolved until she herself became a vampire. So… yeah. That’s why they care. Not very feminist, though.
(9) I always thought Carlisle made Edward do it because he was forcing Edward to rise above himself so that he and Bella would have an easier relationship in a future.
(10) That might just be a difference in preference. Like, I can understand why you’d like more of a contemporary but they bore me to death—if the supernatural elements were taken away Twilight would stop being worth my time, y’know? So I can respect your preference, but not in a universal way.
*sighs* I’m probably like the most annoying commenter ever. XD Sorry, not sorry. Still, you do have a lot of interesting ideas up here and I can totally understand why they would make you not like Twilight. And I always like to have Twilight discussions, even if I am disrespectfully lengthy in my response. Sorry.
Lol, it's fine, I like long comments! And I was looking forward to discussing this with you. :)
Delete1. I didn't necessarily mean that it didn't make sense, because in a way, I do understand it. My point was mostly that one, I still found it infuriating, and two, he shouldn't have been so /obvious/ about it. He drew attention to himself by being so transparent about his feelings and made this situation that much worse.
2. Haha, well, the homeschooling thing was mostly a joke. Like I said about Edward, my point was simply that they were drawing attention to themselves instead of blending in and just being part of the crowd.
And okay, I totally understand that, but in the first book, the "vampire teens," so to speak, took exactly zero part in the community. They had no friends, no social life, they just did their school, hung out amongst themselves, and then went right back to kicking it in the woods. They were even less socialized than society's general (and might I add, false) view of homeschoolers.
So I guess there I'd just say, wanna be a part of the community? Fine. But actually /be a part/. Have a social life. Have friends. And at least /try/ to act normal.
5-7: so what you're saying is, her brain /did/ actually die and ooze invisibly out of her ears? Hehe, just kidding, and I actually could get that. But I guess it's hard for me to believe because I don't even believe in love at first sight, so to say that when their eyes meet, they're utterly bonded to one another forever and ever, amen, is something that will cause me to, at the very least, roll my eyes in annoyance, even if the worldbuilding does explain it.
9. That was only one example, but fair enough. I still say it would've been wiser to put him in the situation where he'd risk her life the least, but I can at least understand that. :)
10. Oh yeah, definitely just a personal preference. Like I said in the post, it's not even something that I strictly disliked or criticized, just something that I really wanted to mention and didn't know where else to, lol. But for sure, that one is just my personal opinion.
My biggest problem with Twilight, I think, is that there were so many obvious, logical choices, but people went with their feelings instead. Now I'm not a /totally/ heartless individual, so obviously there are moments when one should follow one's heart, so to speak. But in Twilight, I didn't feel like the feelings were a strong enough foundation for the decisions they made, especially in situations that affected other people, like 1 and 4, or situations that literally put a life in terrible danger, like 8 and 9. But hey, like I said, these are the rantings of only one girl, and it may be that Twilight just wasn't for me. :)
Not annoying at all. Like I've said before, I love discussing this sort of thing with you! It's fun, plus it causes me to reevaluate my own opinions to make sure they're completely accurate. So thanks for your fantastically long comment :D
Ohhh, wow! You've thought about this very intensely. XD And I have to admit I basically agree. :P I didn't mind Twilight (I only read it like a year or so ago) but the characters did bother me. All the stalkery "love" and the cat-and-mice games. I mean, just state your feelings and move on. (I think I'm too much of a black and white person?! haha. *AHEM*) But I totally agree Edward's mood swings were irritating. And it's totally unrealistic for EVERY guy to like one girl. Although, I kind of concede it might be more because Bella was "new" and the "new" things are always more interesting, right?
ReplyDeleteAs for the eating...>_< They definitely weren't conspicuous about it, right?! I mean, I get: don't eat, because it's gross. But they could've sneaked off to the library or idek GO SOMEWHERE WERE NOT EVERYoNE STARED AND NOTICED. hehh.
I don't think it was an incoherent post at all! :D Very interesting. *nods*
Thanks for stopping by @ Paper Fury!
Haha, yeah, when it comes to books, I tend to think about most things very intensely :p
DeleteWell, if you are, then so am I! lol But I think that was a big part of my annoyance with the book, that I am such a black and white person for a lot of things. Like I said in the above comment, there were so many choices that seemed so obvious and logical to me, yet NO ONE took them. I'm afraid that irked me a little. :p
*nods* Yeah, that's true. Maybe it wasn't so much love, but just that they found her a "shiny new object," so to speak. But still. I found it kind of annoying.
Haha, glad I'm not the only who saw it that way!
Thank you! :D And no problem. :) Thanks for writing an awesome blog and commenting back! :D
lol, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it and that you agree. :)
ReplyDeleteAnd yeah, it was pretty cool being able to find both the good and the bad in the book. It's an interesting series for sure, and I think that, had it gone through a few more edits and some of the above things been fixed, there wouldn't be so much controversy. Because everyone would just agree that it was fantastic, lol
But that is just my opinion. :) Thanks for commenting!
Having never read the books, and having only seen the first movie ages and ages ago, I can't really offer an opinion of my own except that I remember Edward's mood swings and Bella's Bellaness (for lack of a better word), bothering me somewhat. But I also remember having an overall positive impression, so I'm not sure how much any of the individuals bothered me or registered with me enough to bother me. Also, your discussions of Twilight, especially this one, have succeeded in making me want to read the books even more. Because I'm contrary like that. :P
ReplyDeleteA+ on GIF usage. :)
Haha, well, I'm definitely not trying to tell anyone, "don't read the books." Like I mentioned in the post, there are some awesome things in Twilight that make me desperately want to adore it, and if you can look past the problems that I mentioned or they don't bother you at all, then awesome for you! You'll have found another nice series to love. :)
DeleteHaha, thanks! :D